Competency

  • Legal term - ability to understand the nature of an act
  • Adults are competent until determined otherwise by a judge
  • Fairly persistent label; not cross-sectional

If patient is competent...do they have capacity?

Capacity

  • Cross-sectional ability to make informed decisions
  • Medical decision-making (e.g. consent; leaving AMA; etc.) = requires patient to be able to do all 4 below
    • Appreciate situation/illness (appreciation = understanding + application to their personal situation)
    • Appreciate risks, benefits, side-effects, alternatives to proposed intervention
    • Rational reasoning in manipulation of the data (not necessarily reasonable reasoning)
      • Not influenced by effects of medical illness, e.g. depression/suicidality
    • Consistently communicate a choice
  • Frequently requires judgement calls...
  • If patient lacks capacity
    • Find out if patient has health care proxy and/or advance directives
      • Health care proxy = designated power of attorney (DPOA) = legal document empowering a designated person to make decisions in the event the patient cannot
      • Advance directives = living will = document providing instructions for specific situations should the patient be rendered incapacitated
    • If not, follow chain of surrogate decision makers (check state laws)
      • Spouse, adult parent, adult child...
  • Exceptions to requiring informed consent
    • Medical emergency - when delay of treatment poses imminent risk, MD may act in patient's best interest
    • Adjudicated incompetent - court-appointed legal guardian must give consent regardless of pt capacity 
    • Patient waiver - pt may waive the right to informed consent "Do whatever you think is best"
Helpful questions to assess capacity
  • What is the patient’s understanding of the medical problem?
  • What is the patient’s understanding of the MD’s recommendations? Their rationale?
  • What is the patient’s choice? Their rationale?
  • What does the patient anticipate to happen as a result of their choice?
  • What is the patient’s understanding of the r/b/se/a to the recommended intervention? To no intervention?
    • Could they reasonably explain it to another layman?

When to call psych consult for ?capacity

  • Psychiatric process impacting decision-making
    • Psychosis
    • Delirium/dementia
    • Depression/mania
    • Acute intoxication
    • Intellectual disability
  • High risk situations
    • “Price” of consent vs. refusal
    • Patient inconsistency
    • Disagreement among treatment team, family, etc. 

Suicidality

  • Investigating suicidality - patient's subjective report in context of
    • Their history
    • Other behavioral indicators
    • Credible collateral history (when available)
  • Questions to ask
    • Passive SI vs. active SI with intent/plan, e.g. "Do you think of hurting/killing yourself/feel the world would be better without you"; "Have you thought about how you would kill yourself", etc.
    • Access to means - firearms, hanging, prescriptions
    • Protective factors - family, community, religion
  • If patient has SI
    • Closer observation (sitter), elopement protocols
    • Suicide risk assessment - psych eval
author: admin | last edited: March 9, 2018, 12:01 a.m. | pk: 108